Reference check email template: why past managers ignore yours, and the version they answer

Your reference check email is often the reason a referee never replies. A busy former manager opens a vague message from a stranger, cannot tell what you want or how long it will take, and leaves it for later. Days pass, your preferred candidate takes another offer, and you are back to the shortlist.
This guide gives you a reference check email template you can copy, a shorter follow-up, a version for referees overseas, and the small details that make a past manager far more likely to answer within a day or two.
Why most reference request emails get ignored
Referees are not ignoring you on purpose. They are doing a favour for someone who used to work for them, usually in the middle of their own working day. An email that is hard to trust or hard to answer goes to the bottom of the pile.
The four problems that slow a reply
- It looks like spam. A generic subject line, no company name and a link to click can look like a phishing attempt.
- It does not say who the candidate is. A manager who has supervised fifty people needs the full name, the role and roughly when they worked together.
- It does not say what you need. "Could you give a reference?" leaves the referee guessing whether you want a letter, a form or a phone call.
- It hides the time it takes. People say yes to a ten-minute call far more readily than to an open-ended request.
Before you send: three things to sort out first
- Get the candidate's consent. Tell the candidate you are about to contact their referees, and confirm which ones. Privacy rules differ between countries, so follow the ones that apply to you.
- Check the referee's details yourself. Where you can, confirm the business exists and that the person worked there, using the company's own website or main phone line rather than only the number on the CV.
- Decide on the format. A short call usually gives you more than a written form. Offer a call first and questions by email as the fallback.
The reference check email template
Copy this, change the details in square brackets, and send it from your work email address with your full signature.
Subject: Reference for [Candidate full name], [role] at [their old company], 10 minutes
Hello [Referee first name],
I am [your name], [your job title] at [your company]. [Candidate full name] has applied for a [job title] role at [your company] and has named you as a referee from their time as [their role] at [company], around [year] to [year]. They have agreed to this contact.
Would you have 10 minutes for a short call this week? I would like to ask about their main duties, the standard of their work and how they worked with the team. Any of these times suit me: [two or three time slots, with time zone]. If a call is hard, I can send five short questions by email instead.
You can confirm who I am at [company website], or by calling [your company] on [main phone number].
Thank you for your help,
[Your name]
[Job title], [Company]
[Direct phone]
Why this version works
- The subject line gives the candidate's name, the context and the time needed, so the referee knows what it is before opening it.
- The first paragraph answers "who are you and why me?" in three sentences.
- Fixed time slots turn a decision into a simple yes.
- The way to check who you are makes the email easy to trust.
Five short email prompts when a call is not possible
If the referee prefers email, keep the list short and open. Five questions are plenty:
- What was [Candidate]'s role and how long did you work with them?
- What were their main duties day to day?
- What did they do especially well?
- Was there anything they needed support or training with?
- Would you employ them again in a similar role? Why or why not?
For trade roles you will usually want more detail on tools, safety and the type of work. This list of reference check questions for tradespeople covers that in depth.
The follow-up email when there is no reply
Wait two working days, then send one short follow-up in the same thread so the first email is still there.
Subject: Re: Reference for [Candidate full name], [role] at [their old company], 10 minutes
Hello [Referee first name], I know this is a busy time. If a call is easier, I am free [one or two new time slots]. If not, a reply to the five questions below would help just as much. Thank you, [Your name]
If there is still no answer after a second follow-up, tell the candidate and ask for another referee or other evidence. The post on what to do when a referee is not responding walks through the options without treating silence as a red flag.
Adapting the template for referees overseas
Hiring from another country adds time zones, languages and different habits around references. A few small changes help:
- Offer times in their time zone, not only yours. Name both.
- Use plain, short sentences. Your referee may read English as a second language. Avoid idioms like "touch base" or "ballpark".
- Offer a messaging app or video call if that is how business is normally done there, but keep the first contact by email so you have a record.
- Ask for the company's official details. In some countries a stamped service letter on company letterhead is common, and can sit alongside the reference.
The guide to running an overseas reference check has more on confirming that a foreign business and referee are real.
Common mistakes that cost you the reference
| Mistake | What happens | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| Sending from a personal email | The referee doubts the request is real | Use your work address and full signature |
| Attaching a long form | It feels like homework and gets left | Offer a 10-minute call or five questions |
| Asking yes/no questions | You get "yes, fine" and learn nothing | Ask what, how and why questions |
| Chasing every day | The referee feels pressured and stops replying | Two working days between messages |
| Contacting people the candidate did not name | You can damage trust and break privacy rules | Agree every contact with the candidate first |
Recording what you were told
Write short notes straight after each call: who you spoke to, their role, the date, and what they confirmed. Keep facts ("supervised her for two years on night shifts") separate from opinions ("one of the most careful workers I had"). If two referees disagree, that is a question to raise with the candidate, not proof that someone is lying. If you have concerns that a reference may not be genuine, these warning signs of fake references help you decide what to check next.
Getting more evidence before you even send the email
A reference is one piece of evidence. Some candidates now arrive with parts of their work history already backed by documents. On Talent Tabloid, candidates can ask for each role on their profile to be verified; it is confirmed by the person they nominate or through document review. A verified role carries a badge, and the verifier's email and phone are never shown publicly. The employer page explains how searching and contacting candidates works, and if a candidate gives you their username, you can look them up on People Search.
This does not replace your own reference check for the job in front of you, but it can tell you which roles to focus your questions on. Create an employer account to search candidate profiles and see which roles have been verified.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a reference check email be?
Aim for under 150 words in the main message. Say who you are, who the candidate is, what you need and how long it takes, then offer times.
Should I send reference questions in the first email?
Offer a call first and mention that you can send questions instead. If you know the referee prefers email, put the five questions at the end of the first message.
How long should I wait for a referee to reply?
Two working days is a fair wait before a polite follow-up. After a second follow-up with no answer, ask the candidate for another referee.
Can I contact a referee the candidate did not list?
Ask the candidate first. Contacting people without their agreement can damage trust and may break privacy rules where you are.


